In a 2010 article, the NY Times discussed a transformation in what it called “scholarly exchange”. The use of scholarly exchange -or in other words, peer review and collaboration in research -is growing due to the increased use of web-based social media (blogs, forums, comment boxes). Although focused on PhD level works specifically, the article made some generally-applicable observations:
>the use of social media like blogs and wikis speeds up the sharing of knowledge and perspectives considerably, allowing for faster agreement on theories, theorems, proofs, etc.
>the use of open review brings new perspectives from other fields, “making scholarship better” for the case cited in the article
>the use of experts for closed peer review is not going away, as these individuals understand the field-specific significance of research and ideas being presented
Workademia.com exists to promote this kind of scholarly exchange. The site enables MBA students from top 100 programs to disseminate their papers and presentations. What is more, these papers and presentations have already undergone review and grading by subject matter experts -i.e. program professors. Workademia.com then uses an open peer review system that allows a community of business professionals and students to further rate and review the works. Finally, on a quarterly basis a committee of academicians and professionals review the top publications in each category in order to recognize and award the best of the best.
High Quality Content
Grading by professors gives expert academic input. A focused open peer review brings fresh perspectives. Review by a panel helps further identify the leading business publications. All of these methods, on top of internal quality controls of the content, provide a multi-pronged approach that will help ensure high quality publications on workademia.com.
(see our blog post about the workademia.com peer review model here)
Academically Focused
The closing quote of the article noted that academia is “caught in the middle” of an “insular, specialized world of expert scholarship and the open free wheeling exchange on the Web.” The use of an academically-focused social media tool like workademia.com presents a great opportunity to bridge this middle -bringing together the concepts and ideas from academia with the real world perspectives of business professionals.
Scholarly exchange through social media is becoming a new reality for the academic world. Through its MBA generated publications, open peer review and panel reviews, workademia.com wants to ensure its success.
Regards,
B